Making double sword finessable
Moderators: Forum Moderators, Active DMs, Contributors
Making double sword finessable
As the title, I think this weapon really needs the Katana treatment, offering SOME reason to ever take it as a weapon.
Thoughts?
Thoughts?
Re: Making double sword finessable
The weapon is fine.
Re: Making double sword finessable
How so? It precludes weapon finesse (but still needs 9 ranger, 15 dex, or half orc), does less damage than katanas, and you can't swap to sword and board if things get hairy. You get 2 AB for it, and only need 1 essence instead of two but you trade all of the above. What's better about it, or any of the double weapons for that matter? Is there something I'm missing?
Re: Making double sword finessable
It serves the niche for rangers and half orcs. The +2 AB and large size also make it great for disarm. It's not as good as scimitar or kukri stuff but it's decent for the above.
Re: Making double sword finessable
Why is this always the standard response lately? Why is nothing allowed to be as "good" as those two weapons? Just being unable to use a shield is a huge disadvantage by your own words, as well as having worse crits and requiring 4 feats to use.Cortex wrote:It's not as good as scimitar or kukri stuff but it's decent for the above.
Moving a few more weapons into the spotlight besides scimmy/rapier/kukri/scythe would add a lot more refreshing variety.
Re: Making double sword finessable
Because maybe it's those weapons that are the problem, not the other 95%?
(Just guessing)
(Just guessing)
Re: Making double sword finessable
I think that's the consensus, but there also hasn't been any movement on bringing scimitar and rapier into line with the rest of the weapons.
Kukri is fine I think. It requires a great and is super easy to disarm.
Kukri is fine I think. It requires a great and is super easy to disarm.
Re: Making double sword finessable
Im all for starting a serious movement to bring them in line. Theres been a half dozen really good suggestions to make weapons aside from those more viable.Kirito wrote:Because maybe it's those weapons that are the problem, not the other 95%?
(Just guessing)
-
- Posts: 2901
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2015 2:31 am
- Location: Dancing on the line between sarcasm and irony
Re: Making double sword finessable
Just speaking of double-sided weapons...
All of them are relatively subpar and lack the versatility of being able to be used with shields.
Not to mention, you still need to burn an exotic feat into them.
As STR weapons, they are particularly awkward to use since only rangers and half-orcs get ambidexterity, which requires a 15 dex investment otherwise. Too much hassle for a gain that is honestly more thematic than mechanic.
I don't see why not make them finesseable. If anything, it allows for more build flexibility with a weapon that is not remarkably powerful to begin with.
All of them are relatively subpar and lack the versatility of being able to be used with shields.
Not to mention, you still need to burn an exotic feat into them.
As STR weapons, they are particularly awkward to use since only rangers and half-orcs get ambidexterity, which requires a 15 dex investment otherwise. Too much hassle for a gain that is honestly more thematic than mechanic.
I don't see why not make them finesseable. If anything, it allows for more build flexibility with a weapon that is not remarkably powerful to begin with.
Misc Changes, with the Feats and Skills sublinks.
Available races
Spell Changes
Class Mechanics
Command Guide
Take a look before asking your questions!
Available races
Spell Changes
Class Mechanics
Command Guide
Take a look before asking your questions!
-
- Posts: 2364
- Joined: Mon Sep 08, 2014 4:34 am
Re: Making double sword finessable
They're pretty bad even for ranger, since you're stuck with light armor on a strength build.
Rolled: Helene d'Arque, Sara Lyonall
Shelved: Kels Vetian, Cin ys'Andalis, Saul Haidt
Playing: Oshe Jordain
Shelved: Kels Vetian, Cin ys'Andalis, Saul Haidt
Playing: Oshe Jordain
-
- Posts: 54
- Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2017 5:54 pm
- Location: the land of the free
Re: Making double sword finessable
Nerfing the dreaded 18-20 weapons nerfs melees in generalGiftstoff wrote:Im all for starting a serious movement to bring them in line. Theres been a half dozen really good suggestions to make weapons aside from those more viable.Kirito wrote:Because maybe it's those weapons that are the problem, not the other 95%?
(Just guessing)
It doesn't really make a difference in direct competition between melees, since you'll be seeing high AC duels here where you can't really confirm those higher range crits, anyways.
The only thing this would ensure, is to bring the users of optimal weapons on the same level as the other weapons against low AC targets (e.g. casters), which serves... which purpose exactly?
Tbh, I like the approach so far, to incentivise the use of """unoptimal""" weapons; By adding the moonblade and the runic waraxe, a niche for use of these weapons has opened up. I'd rather see the devs continuing down this path.
Re: Making double sword finessable
The way to go are special weapons done from these relative sub optimal weapons. Howerver UMd requirment is almost always so high that they will never be largely spread.
Re: Making double sword finessable
What might be interesting to see is if the double-sided weapons received a bonus to their offhand damage equal to 1/2 the weilder's STR, effectively making them a way to dual weild while getting full STR to both hands, instead of 1/2 strength. This would be a nice buff, and also cement them as "That weapon Orcs and Rangers really like to use, since they can access dual weilding without the dex requirement, meaning they have more Strength to benefit from the offhand boost."
Re: Making double sword finessable
I am totally impartial as a fan of Final Fantasy 9, but I don't see any balance implications with the suggested update: DEX characters should still be using a shield for toe-to-toe combat, the double-sword could work as a gimmick to increase your out-of-stealth burst, but even still the minor buff would still be situational and, in my humbledore, overshadowed by the AC bonus from sword-and-boarding.
While we're at it, might I suggest the following suggestions full of flavonoids:
-Doublemace: make it work with Monk UBAB for some kewl STR monks
-Doubleaxe: if possible, make mainhand attacks damage 1.5 STR and offhand attacks 1.0 STR; if not possible, increase the base weapon damage
While we're at it, might I suggest the following suggestions full of flavonoids:
-Doublemace: make it work with Monk UBAB for some kewl STR monks
-Doubleaxe: if possible, make mainhand attacks damage 1.5 STR and offhand attacks 1.0 STR; if not possible, increase the base weapon damage
Characters: all poor babies suffering from neglect
-
- Posts: 882
- Joined: Mon Sep 08, 2014 8:33 pm
- Location: California
Re: Making double sword finessable
It would be awesome if double weapons could have a shield AC bonus equal to that of the enhancement bonus of the weapon. It could reflect the weapons being used to parry blows and so on.
But I think weapons can only allow deflection AC on them. Still, that might be something too, so that a helm slot could be used for other things.
But I think weapons can only allow deflection AC on them. Still, that might be something too, so that a helm slot could be used for other things.
Re: Making double sword finessable
Or, you know, a bonus to parry;)Griefmaker wrote:It would be awesome if double weapons could have a shield AC bonus equal to that of the enhancement bonus of the weapon. It could reflect the weapons being used to parry blows and so on.
But I think weapons can only allow deflection AC on them. Still, that might be something too, so that a helm slot could be used for other things.
-
- Posts: 281
- Joined: Wed Aug 30, 2017 5:08 pm
Re: Making double sword finessable
Every X amount of parry you get Y amount of shield AC up to a max of +5.Kirito wrote:Or, you know, a bonus to parry;)Griefmaker wrote:It would be awesome if double weapons could have a shield AC bonus equal to that of the enhancement bonus of the weapon. It could reflect the weapons being used to parry blows and so on.
But I think weapons can only allow deflection AC on them. Still, that might be something too, so that a helm slot could be used for other things.
-
- Posts: 2901
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2015 2:31 am
- Location: Dancing on the line between sarcasm and irony
Re: Making double sword finessable
Kirito wrote:Or, you know, a bonus to parry;)Griefmaker wrote:It would be awesome if double weapons could have a shield AC bonus equal to that of the enhancement bonus of the weapon. It could reflect the weapons being used to parry blows and so on.
But I think weapons can only allow deflection AC on them. Still, that might be something too, so that a helm slot could be used for other things.
I'm not a fan of how parry works.
I took it with my character, and it's just...
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah...
Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuugh...
Not for me.
Misc Changes, with the Feats and Skills sublinks.
Available races
Spell Changes
Class Mechanics
Command Guide
Take a look before asking your questions!
Available races
Spell Changes
Class Mechanics
Command Guide
Take a look before asking your questions!
Re: Making double sword finessable
If parry could actually block attacks up to your max, and not just one attack per flurry, effectively capping you at 3 parries despite being a monk with 8, it might be worth using. If it also didn't ignore 20's, and actually made your attacks at highest BAB, it also might be worth using. At the moment though, the skill is just functionally absolutely broken unless you're fighting only 1 opponent with 3 attacks or less. So... unhasted spellswords, or unbuffed clerics, or something.
Re: Making double sword finessable
Parry is situational, and especially useful in mix ups in 1v1 duels.
Re: Making double sword finessable
Losing probably 4 of your 7 attacks to still get hit by 1-3 of theirs still at a decreasing attack bonus and not working if they roll 20's (which is the biggest threat to high AC or IE'ing characters to begin with, something parry doesn't help with) is not situational or useful for mixups. It's objectively worse than just plowing through then 7 times a round hasted, or 5 if you're clever, not using double weapons, and just pull out a shield for 5-6 more AC, which might let you use normal expertise instead of improved and instantly gain 5 AB.
Re: Making double sword finessable
How is it a mixup? Won't you just get hit more and attack less? Or is that the mixup like a 'sandbag' strat?Cortex wrote:Parry is situational, and especially useful in mix ups in 1v1 duels.
edit;
http://nwn.wikia.com/wiki/Parry
So you need to roll 10 higher then their attack roll, you can't expertise while doing it, but you're basically capped at 3 attacks per round?
-
- Posts: 2364
- Joined: Mon Sep 08, 2014 4:34 am
Re: Making double sword finessable
To expand on Cortex's point: Parry is situationally useful
if you invest heavily in it. You need somewhere on the order of 60+ parry at level 30 just to be able to block reliably. That said, a Dex character geared for parry can hit over 70, and that's without skill focus or improved parry. Add in epic dodge and you can pretty much ignore anyone with four or fewer APR. Also note that while parry doesn't work on 20s, it CAN prevent the threat confirmation roll. Finally, there's the Arelith changes to parry, where ripostes get +5 AB and a portion of your parry skill as extra damage (~23 for the 70+ build mentioned above). This wrecks in 1v1 duels, at least until your opponent pulls a gonne on you - at which point you turn parry off and go for the face again. It's a style that takes some getting used to, but having fought it I can confirm that it can be very effective.
That said, what does this have to do with twinblades? With them as a strength weapon, I don't see them being a parrying character's weapon of choice!
if you invest heavily in it. You need somewhere on the order of 60+ parry at level 30 just to be able to block reliably. That said, a Dex character geared for parry can hit over 70, and that's without skill focus or improved parry. Add in epic dodge and you can pretty much ignore anyone with four or fewer APR. Also note that while parry doesn't work on 20s, it CAN prevent the threat confirmation roll. Finally, there's the Arelith changes to parry, where ripostes get +5 AB and a portion of your parry skill as extra damage (~23 for the 70+ build mentioned above). This wrecks in 1v1 duels, at least until your opponent pulls a gonne on you - at which point you turn parry off and go for the face again. It's a style that takes some getting used to, but having fought it I can confirm that it can be very effective.
That said, what does this have to do with twinblades? With them as a strength weapon, I don't see them being a parrying character's weapon of choice!
Rolled: Helene d'Arque, Sara Lyonall
Shelved: Kels Vetian, Cin ys'Andalis, Saul Haidt
Playing: Oshe Jordain
Shelved: Kels Vetian, Cin ys'Andalis, Saul Haidt
Playing: Oshe Jordain
Re: Making double sword finessable
Allowing it to be finessable AND adding in some unique variants to the weapon would help. Being able to parry with it would be neat, but currently STR base makes that infeasible.
-
- Posts: 1860
- Joined: Mon Sep 08, 2014 4:44 pm
Re: Making double sword finessable
There are already plans for a lot of weapons going forward. Many of those involve offering alternatives that are stronger than available scimitars/rapiers (e.g. Moonblades).
No, double weapons won't be made finessable.
No, double weapons won't be made finessable.